New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies Prediction (July 24): Odds, Pick & Analysis

New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies · July 24, 2026 · 6:45 PM EDT · Photo: ESPN
The New York Yankees and Philadelphia Phillies enter this matchup with nearly identical offensive profiles, both posting a .236 batting average through the season. Yet beneath that surface similarity lies a meaningful difference in execution and momentum that shapes this July 24 contest in Philadelphia.
Tonight's Odds
Probable Pitchers
New York Yankees
RHP Cam Schlittler
Philadelphia Phillies
LHP Jesus Luzardo
The Phillies' lineup features Brandon Marsh's team-leading .292 average and Kyle Schwarber's imposing .909 OPS, anchored by 33 home runs—the most on the roster. Bryce Harper adds another dimension with a .256 average and .856 OPS. Philadelphia has scored 4.35 runs per game, powered by 135 total home runs. However, the Phillies enter this game on a two-game losing streak and have posted a 5-5 record over their last ten games, suggesting inconsistency at the plate despite individual excellence. The home team's pitching staff carries a 4.27 ERA, and they'll rely on Jesús Luzardo to deliver on the mound. Luzardo brings a 3.43 ERA and a 9-4 record into the start. Philadelphia's injury situation has deepened with Brad Keller, Garrett Stubbs, Lou Trivino III, and Tanner Banks all sidelined.
The Yankees counter with Ben Rice's exceptional .277 average and .956 OPS, complemented by his team-leading 30 home runs. Cody Bellinger provides secondary offensive support at .256 with a .764 OPS. New York has generated 4.71 runs per game—nearly four-tenths of a run better than Philadelphia's output—and owns 147 home runs on the season. The Yankees' recent form has been sharper: they've won seven of their last ten games and currently ride a one-game winning streak. More importantly, the Yankees' pitching staff boasts a 3.38 ERA, substantially better than their opponent's mark. Cam Schlittler, the probable starter for New York, brings a stellar 2.20 ERA and a 9-6 record to Citizens Bank Park. The Yankees are missing Carlos Rodón and Giancarlo Stanton to injury, but their depth has allowed them to maintain strong offensive output.
The pitching advantage clearly tilts toward New York. Schlittler's 2.20 ERA represents elite-level performance, and he faces a Phillies lineup that, while talented, has struggled for consistency recently. Luzardo's 3.43 ERA is respectable but trails Schlittler's dominance significantly. The Yankees' superior run-scoring rate (4.71 versus 4.35 per game) combined with their recent winning momentum and pitching edge makes them the stronger play at plus money. Philadelphia's deeper injury list and two-game skid further diminish their appeal. The Yankees, despite being the road team, possess the statistical foundation and current form to secure a victory.
Best Bet
New York Yankees (+104)
Based on the matchup analysis, recent form, and line value, New York Yankees (+104) is our top play for this game.


